Detective journal
Case-solving games: examine the evidence before you accuse
A case-solving game asks you to connect evidence into a defensible explanation. Start with the timeline, separate observations from claims and test the weakest part of an alibi before accusing anyone.
By Criminal Atlas · Published · Updated

What makes an online case worth investigating?
A useful mystery gives you things to compare: a time on a document, a person’s statement, a route between two locations. Your job is to decide what each item proves and where an explanation stops fitting. More documents do not automatically mean a better case; the relationships between them create the deduction.
Here is a small fictional exercise written for this guide. It is independent of the published game catalog. The question is whether an alibi survives the evidence, not whether you can guess a culprit from a short description.
The missing envelope: a timeline exercise
A sealed envelope is seen in an archive at 8:10 PM and reported missing at 8:20 PM. The archive has one entrance covered by a continuously recording corridor camera. The recording and times below are reliable facts for this exercise.
Evidence available to you
| Item | What it records |
|---|---|
| Inés at reception | Reception footage shows her there continuously from 8:00 to 8:25 PM. |
| Nora’s visit | The corridor camera records Nora leaving the archive at 8:05 PM. |
| Mateo’s statement | He says he stayed on the terrace from 8:00 to 8:30 PM. |
| The corridor recording | Mateo enters the archive at 8:14 PM and leaves at 8:16 PM. |
| Envelope sighting | A staff member sees the envelope inside at 8:10 PM. |
What can you conclude?
Mateo’s claim that he never left the terrace conflicts with the recording. Nora’s recorded visit ends before the envelope is last seen. Inés’s location is supported during the relevant interval. These distinctions tell you which statement to challenge first.
They do not prove that Mateo stole the envelope. The exercise does not show what he did inside or where the envelope went. A good follow-up is: “The corridor camera shows you entering at 8:14. Why did you go in?” Then compare his explanation with what else you can establish.
The difference matters in an investigation: finding a lie opens a line of inquiry. A final accusation needs evidence connecting the person to the act, not merely evidence that they concealed a visit.
A practical method for the next case
- Read the question. Are you identifying a culprit, explaining a disappearance or locating a stolen object?
- Build a factual timeline. Keep a recorded event separate from the time a suspect remembers.
- Label what you know. “The card opened a door” is narrower than “its owner entered alone.”
- Compare explanations. Ask which evidence each theory explains and which evidence it leaves unresolved.
- Accuse only when the key facts connect. A strong theory survives the evidence that initially looked inconvenient.
Try that process in a playable investigation
In Criminal Atlas, you explore a fictional scene, review a growing case file and question characters by text. You can start as a guest and examine the scene, file and board. Email verification is required when you interrogate, request a hint or accuse.
Published investigations are free during launch and generally take 30–90 minutes or more. If you want a shorter exercise with all clues provided and true, the current Daily Case takes about 5–10 minutes and needs no account.

Royal Street Brass Switch
At a private party on Royal Street, the cornet of a jazz legend, worth three million dollars, turns out to be a fake. Everyone at the party is a suspect, but the real question is when the switch happened.
Frequently asked questions
Is this a real criminal case?
No. The missing-envelope exercise and the game’s crimes are fictional. The exercise is a teaching example, not a playable catalog case.
Does catching a lie identify the culprit?
Not by itself. A lie can justify further questions, but the evidence must still support the accusation you make.
Do online case files always include AI conversations?
No. Some formats provide fixed documents and answers. Text interrogations are a feature of this game’s longer investigations.


